The first couple of chapters of Genesis picture the world God created. A world that he pronounced as being ‘very good’. But then, in chapter 3, Adam and Eve ate the forbidden fruit followed by death’s entrance into the world. But was this death that came with eating from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil physical or spiritual? And did it only impact Adam and Eve and their progeny? Or did it impact all life on the earth?
Some Background Assumptions
Before attempting an answer to this question, I think it is important to identify some key assumptions that I make.
- The sovereign God has been accomplishing his purpose in this world from creation. Nothing humanity has done has interfered with the fulfillment of that purpose.
- The Bible is a reliable and faithful record of what God has done in the world. And it is true in all that it teaches and affirms. We may not always understand it correctly. But it is never in error.
- The created order itself bears faithful witness to its creator. It is a less detailed witness than the Bible, but a witness none-the-less. But, like the Bible, we do not always understand it correctly.
- The historicity of Adam and Eve as the parents of all of humanity, while debated by those who hold to the above assumptions, is beyond the scope of this article and will be assumed to be true. This means that human death before the Fall is not under discussion. Although its eventual possibility without the Fall is.
Two Contrasting Views
There are two contrasting views about the creation that impact how we view the origin of death. There are many variations on these, but I believe these simplified models help to explain the position of most people concerning the relationship of death and the fall.
The first view is one that is held by many in the evangelical community. It is that the creation occurred on the order of a few thousand years ago. Most holding this view also hold that there was no death in the world prior to the Fall. But that, as a result of man’s fall, all of creation was impacted, including the intrusion of death as the fate of all living things.
The second view is that the creation occurred on the order of billions of years ago. This view is held by some in the evangelical community as well as most of the rest of Christianity and nearly all of secular science. This position holds that as long as life has existed on earth, it has been accompanied by death.
When we talk about death, a valid consideration is defining the scope of death. Some who might deny the death of humanity before the Fall, might accept the death of lessor creatures. The death of a plant, a bacterium, or an insect might be quite acceptable. While the death of a sentient creature, especially humans, would not be.
For the purposes of this article I am referring to the death of sentient life. And that would include death as a natural outcome for Adam and Eve apart from the Fall. So, the question becomes, was there death among animals before the Fall? And would Adam and Eve, along with all animals, eventually have died if humanity had not fallen?
The Witness of Scripture
There are a handful of passages in the Scripture that speak to the issue of death in the world. Space does not allow for a through examination of them. But it is important to take them into account when examining this topic.
The first of these passages is from Genesis 1:31. When God looks at all his work in creation, he pronounces it as very good. If physical death is viewed as something that is bad, and it was in existence from the beginning, then it is hard to see the creation as being ‘very good’.
A second passage is Genesis 2:17. God gave Adam the freedom to eat from any tree in the garden. Except the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. Adam is told that when he eats from this tree he will certainly die. This would seem to imply that if Adam did not eat from it, he would not experience death.
Paul refers to Adam’s sin and its consequences in Romans 5:12-17. Paul says that sin and death entered the world through Adam. And that all die because all sin. But life comes to all who believe in Christ.
A final passage is in Romans 8:20-21. In this passage Paul says that the whole creation was subjected to frustration. This was done in hope that the creation itself would be set free from its bondage to decay and brought into the glorious freedom of the children of God. Many see this as referring to the created order being directly impacted by Adam’s fall. Including the introduction of death.
The Witness of Science
Many believers view the scientific endeavor with skepticism, believing that it is at heart an attempt to discredit faith in God. And it must be admitted that there are some who mix a philosophical bias against belief in God with their science. But science, at its heart, is simply the attempt to gain understanding in how the creation functions. It seeks to understand how our world works. As a believer, I view science as an aid to understand the glories of creation and its creator.
But science paints a very different picture of death from what some see in the pages of Scripture. Science affirms that the earth we live on is very old, and that life has been in existence on it for over 3 billion years. Much longer than humans have existed. And death has been a part of that from the beginning.
Was There Death Before the Fall?
Before the Fall, did animals grow old and die? Or did lions eat zebras? If Adam and Eve, as well as their progeny, had not sinned, would they be living on earth today, along with every animal and person who has ever been born?
The first thing to note is that nowhere in the Bible is the claim ever made that there was no death prior to the Fall. Adam is told that he would die if he ate the forbidden fruit. But that is quite different than claiming that all life would end in death if he ate.
And Paul’s discussion of death coming through Adam and life through Jesus would not seem to fit well with a discussion of physical life and death. The life that came through Jesus was spiritual life. So, it would make the most sense, at least to me, to see that the death that comes through Adam was also spiritual death.
The Goodness of Death
Maybe the biggest objection to death before the Fall has to do with the goodness of death. Can a world that includes death be rightly called ‘very good’ by God? Humans generally fear death. And we identify it as an evil that will eventually come to us all. We might imagine a perfect world as being one without death. A world where we would mature to some perfect state and never grow old.
But is death evil? At least for the one who walks with God? Does not death usher us into God’s presence? While it is true that Adam and Eve walked with God in the garden, it would seem like the hope we have is something that is beyond their experience there in the garden.
And, is there anything wrong with a lion killing and eating a zebra? What if there was no death and every creature was an herbivore? How long would it take before the world was overrun with animals eating every plant in sight? In reality, predators are necessary in order to maintain healthy and stable populations of all kinds of life. Death is really an essential component in a healthy world. A world that is “very good”.
No Reason to Exclude Death
I do not believe there is any reason to hold to a creation where physical death did not exist prior to humanities fall in the garden. From an old earth perspective, there is really no question about death before the Fall. There is no way to escape it.
But even from a young earth perspective, there is no reason to deny that death was originally a part of the creation. The Bible does not demand a deathless creation. Nor would a growing population of animals be healthy for long without death to maintain a balance.
This article was originally published at Bible Study Tools on July 17, 2020
The views expressed here are solely mine and do not necessarily reflect those of any other person, group, or organization. While I believe they reflect the teachings of the Bible, I am a fallible human and subject to misunderstanding. Please feel free to leave any comments or questions about this post in the comments section below. I am always interested in your feedback.
If you have found value in this post, please consider subscribing to A Clay Jar so that you don’t miss any other posts.
2 thoughts on “Was There Death in the World Before the Fall?”
From what I understand, you are attempting to say that death did exist prior to the Fall of man, and here is why I disagree.
1st – the general idea of “Paradise” that will come when the New heaven and earth come into being is described to have ravenous animals calmly interacting with their prey. In other words, animals that hunt, no longer hunt (Isaiah 11: 6). Furthermore, the idea of a “New Heaven” is best identified as the antithesis of what our current world is like. And the degradation of our current world is only identified as the result of the first imperfect decision (Adam and Eve eating the fruit). There are no “problems” that man has to contend with until the fall. I think this leads us to conclude that what existed before the first imperfect decision was what will exist after everything is made new. In other words, the original creation that man corrupted, was what will be in the New Heaven.
2nd – Predators are not a necessary part of a healthy world. For example, humanity survives by eating meat correct? Yes, but that was not what man was made to eat prior to the fall. There are a few implications of this in Genesis; one bing in Genesis 9 where God had to permit Noah to eat meat. This would imply that animals also can survive without eating meat. Note: The fact that predators no longer prey on their natural prey shows how this shifts in the new heaven and new earth.
3rd – Physical death ushers us into God’s presence because we belong to Jesus; and not for any other reason. In this case, the passage that best identifies what the Christian experiences is “all things work together for good for those who love God and are called according to His purposes” (Romans 8: 28) everything the Christian experiences brings him closer to God.
4th – Also, “overpopulation” in a world like ours is easily solved by God when he disables the possibility of childbirth; which we know he can do because of the way he closed wombs in different parts of the Old Testament. Therefore, God can easily stop death by way of animals hunting other animals and simultaneously maintain a specific population number.
These are my thoughts on why I generally think death was not present prior to the fall of man but I can be wrong. I appreciate you writing this article and would enjoy hearing what you think about what I said. God Bless.
At least a portion of your reply assumes that “Paradise”, or the Garden of Eden, was all that there was. Yet it was only a small part of the world. It was a garden that God planted in the East. Discounting the possibility of humanity outside the garden, surely there were animals that did not live in Eden.
If indeed the earth is only 6000 years old, and the fall occurred soon after creation, then it may be that nothing had died prior to the fall. But, if the earth is much older than that, and I believe it is, then it would seem highly unlikely that there was no death until humanity came along and upset the apple cart.
Predators are indeed a necessary part of a healthy ecosystem, at least in the world we live in. In place where the non-human predators have been eliminated, the ecological balance is disrupted and the herbivores end up starving or sickly because they over graze the available food and the weak are not culled.
I do understand your reluctance to accept death before the fall. It was a challenge for me because of my upbringing and early years in the church. And because it is appealing to see death as an enemy that was not originally a part of the creation. But I have come to accept it, not as something bad, but as a natural part of the world God created.